Thursday, September 2, 2010

How could it be dangerous to be smart? Sherman Alexie's "Superman and Me"

I must first of all begin by saying that "Superman and Me" by Sherman Alexie felt like a punch in the face to me for some reason. I enjoy reading about history, mostly early european history, and I usually stay away from early American history because there is a part of me that feels shame for what happened to the Native Americans during the Manifest Destiny era. I can't imagine the horrors involved with being fully uprooted from your culture and environment and placed in some of the least savory places to live. I doubt if my ancestors were involved with any of this personally but its not really about my ancestry from a specific country, but it is about my ancestry as a human. Throughout history there are examples of where Americans have stepped in and defended humanity where there have been injustices against humans. It was during America's Infancy that some of the greatest injustices were wrought. It is this legacy that Sherman Alexie is very aware and not so subtly punches you with in his writing.

       For a Native American to be smart, especially at a young age was a dangerous thing for Sherman. When you are aware and knowledgeable of many things around you you become dangerous because you may uncover truths as well as raise the bar for everyone around you. This could be very dangerous for you because there may be many others around you that don't want to have higher expectations from parents, teachers, or friends. You may uncover something, like the past, that nobody wants to talk about. Maybe our teacher is not expecting you to be intelligent and may even put you down as opposed to help bringing out your talents. Maybe your parents will resent you being smarter than them instead of being proud of you.
       When I was in school "Nerdy" was not cool and those kids were picked on the most. I think it was dangerous for them in different ways though. I think Sherman's danger was apparent within his entire community. There weren't any expectations of anyone becoming a somebody mostly due to the racism within our society. Sherman says that his family was poor by most peoples standards, but the fact that one of his parents could find a minimum wage job once in awhile meaned that they were middle class to reservation standards. If your smart then you would be expected to find your way out and bring yourself up to the normal standards of society. It woul also be dangerous to be smart if when in the process of becoming smart you realize how cruel our society can be as well as how easy it would be to just hang up your cletes and go home to join the others who couldn't make it. Its like being smart can also be your enemy. I am really happy to see that Sherman could pull through all this and build his own road.

4 comments:

  1. Hi Eric,

    Thanks for your thoughtful reflection! I've read other essays by Alexie and we'll watch his film "Smoke Signals" in our class; he has no problem sharing his observations of reservation life and the effects of colonization. His topics are sometimes difficult to read, but it's honest. I think he would argue that the U.S. has to address its collective history, whether good or bad, in order to move forward and heal. Alexie saves himself, in part, by analyzing the history of his people in order to break free from oppression.

    Lauren

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you regarding "nerd" in school and that the other students feel threaten and make fun of them and feel that they are dangerous; in fact these behavior comes from weakness and unfortunately we as people in society are promoting anything bad and this is always a problem for me why "bad" is " good" and "good " is not really "good or attractive or right"? Why we are not supportive of our smart people? why we don't try to learn more and be smart and act smart? why when one of us is acting smart we are blocking his/her way?
    We, as a society, need to change our approach to life and what is in it in a right way.
    We should encourage our smart pals while they can help themselves and others.They can inspire others like Alexie to open close doors and start living life.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you about how being smart could mean you raise the standard for everyone else, If a Native American showed how intelligent they were they could risk the wall they had put up between themselves and the immigrants that wished (and succeeded) in secluding them and taking over their land.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Eric,
    I appreciate your critical thought on the subject...it was also in line with some of my thoughts as well. What brought those indian children to 'our schools' was at a great loss of their own and unfortunately if they don't follow a path of education they are likely to live a life of poverty because their way of life has been destroyed. Also, I think it is very challenging to speak of painful things of the past as you said in so many words..

    ReplyDelete